jump to navigation

Ted Haggard Hawks Software January 19, 2007

Posted by techgrrl in in my opinion.
trackback

I attended the launch event for Windows Vista here in Indianapolis earlier this week. As I was listening to the speakers present, I was very much put in the mind of the clips of Pastor Ted Haggard in the movie Jesus Camp. The presenters that Microsoft uses often have the word ‘evangelist’ in their job titles, as in Product Evangelist. I understand what they’re trying to say with this kind of job title, but I can’t help but wonder if the individuals who fill these roles have taken the title literally.

I would describe both of the presenters that I saw as having that typical Christian appearance. They had on their business casual uniform and clean cut haircuts. They reminded me of some of the young men from Haggard’s New Life Church who took on new roles after Haggard left the church. Their appearance alone isn’t what cinches the deal for me. It’s also the way that they presented themselves and their content. The morning presenter was a little on the goofy side, very similar to the DJ Smiley who works on WZPL here in Indy. As I understand it, Smiley comes from an evangelical backgroud. The style of the afternoon presenter closely resembled the style of Ted Haggard. He told similar kinds of jokes and used gimmicks to capture the attention (and hopefully allegiance) of the audience. I wish I had some specific examples, but I didn’t write any down. This was just my impression sitting in the audience.

I’ve been concerned for awhile about the use of evangelism to sell products and recruit employees. When The Home Depot came to Indy a few years back, they used an evalengical approach to recruit people. From what I’ve been told by people who attended some of these sessions, they found themselves drawn in and saying ‘yes’ even though they knew rationally that it was too good to be true. I wonder if the evangelical style causes people to suspend their rational selves and allow faith to take over. If it happens at church, it seems like it could happen at a seminar too.

If Microsoft and other large companies have to resort to this kind of trickery and gimmicks to sell their wares, then this is capitalism at its worst. To evoke the behavioral patterns that people display at church in the marketplace is manipulative and irresponsible. I don’t think these individual presenters are to blame. Rather, I think the language of evangelism took over and influenced Microsoft’s systemic behavior as it relates to their hiring and retention practices. One way to know for sure – How much diversity is there among the group of presenters and product evangelists? If they all look the same, then that’s a problem.

When people stop thinking critically and instead give themselves over to whichever company ignites their passions, then we’re opening ourselves up to manipulation. If it’s happening in selling and recruiting, then this has a significant impact on our economy. Employees can be convinced to give up good paying jobs with benefits to take jobs with companies they “believe” in. Business people can be convinced to buy products that their companies don’t need simply because they want to belong and squelch that uneasy feeling of uncertainty that happens when you step outside the group. It makes me nervous for our future.

Comments»

1. Praise The Home Depot! « IndyNess - January 19, 2007

[...] The Home Depot! Jump to Comments I don’t know how much of you read my tech blog, but I posted over there about the use of evangelism in selling products and recruiting employees. Here’s [...]

2. david - April 27, 2007

Vanessa – interesting perspective and article. I was looking into Product Evangelists and happened upon your site. Personally, I don’t think there is as much to worry about as you imply. Surely, this is just a new and better targeted, well informed, grass roots method of PR? And, if an organisation’s objective is to increase sales, profits etc, then why not resort to a different tactic? On the contrary, I think it’s a brilliant concept. Business all to frequently borrows management methods from sport; time to borrow from the Bible. It’s time to step outside the box and go back to basics: good old word of mouth from those can can speak eloquently to the masses. In religious terms, isn’t this what characters from the old and new testament did? And look at their success. Kudos to the new evangelist.

3. Tom Murphy - January 15, 2008

Vanessa – I have serious issues in “product evangelism” like yourself; As a Christian evangelical, too few of us have forgotten that we are merely vessels that God uses for His purposes. We don’t “sell” Jesus, He already purchased us at Calvary.

Our cause is to see God glorified, magnified, and made known to a dead and dying world. To use Christianese for our own personal advantage in the workplace would cause me to question why a person is doing so – For God’s glorify or for their own pocketbooks.

In fact, the one time that Jesus is enraged (flipping Temple tables) is when these types are using His Father’s house for their own gain.

In essence, Christians (followers of the Way, the Truth, and the Life) are merely here to share God’s Word, Jesus Christ, with the world (John 1:!-2) with grace and seasoned with salt (Col 4:6). If those eternal souls reject, we are to dust off our sandals and move on to those that listen (Mat 10:14).

His message should be our message and should be led by the Holy Spirit’s guiding hand. The work of the Holy Spirit does not conflict with fundamental teachings of Scripture as initially understood in its original context in the location, to the audience, and by the human authors as noted by the early church Fathers and martyrs.

As most other evangelicals understand, we believe that the Bible is the inspired Word of God written by the Holy Spirit through the vessels of human authors…

At a more benign level, a corporation “evangelizing” their product has nothing to do with Christ, but are typically led by a loose conglomeration of lukewarm Christians who have not heeded the call to do so for Christ in their daily lives.

As a warning to the lukewarm from Scripture, they might want to read (Rev 3:15-22)…

Hope this doesn’t come across too harsh…Just don’t think that Scripture should ever be used willy-nilly…

Abiding in Him,
Tom

4. Jeff - February 18, 2008

Re: Tom

In the immortal words of Sgt. Hulka “Lighten up Francis”.